
Performance Marketing
6 min read
26 Oct 2026
How to structure a paid media agency fee model that fits your business

Rob Simpkins
Co-Founder / Head of Service
The way an agency is paid shapes the relationship more than most contracts acknowledge. It influences what the agency recommends, where it spends its time and how comfortable it is telling you that a budget increase isn’t worth it. Yet fee models are often chosen by default, because it’s what the agency proposed or what the previous agency used, rather than because it suits the business.
There’s no single correct model. The right one depends on how stable your budget is, how well you can measure commercial outcomes and how much of the strategic work you want to keep in-house. Below is a practical comparison, followed by what belongs in the contract and how to judge whether you’re getting value.
The main fee models
Percentage of spend. The agency charges a set percentage of media spend, often with a minimum monthly fee. It’s simple and scales naturally as accounts grow and need more management. The weakness is that it ties the agency’s income to spend rather than results, and it can overpay for large, stable accounts where workload doesn’t rise in line with budget. It suits businesses with variable or seasonal budgets, provided budget changes are agreed rather than proposed unilaterally.
Fixed retainer. A flat monthly fee based on an agreed scope of work. Costs are predictable and the agency has no financial reason to push spend. The risk is scope drift: as needs change, the retainer can stop reflecting the actual work, leading either to an under-resourced account or to friction over extras. It suits businesses with stable budgets and a clearly defined scope.
Tiered percentage. The percentage decreases as spend passes set thresholds, for example a higher rate on the first band of spend and a lower rate above it. This reflects the reality that management effort doesn’t scale linearly with budget. It’s a sensible refinement for larger accounts that want to keep a spend-linked model.
Hybrid. A base retainer that covers the core work, with a variable element on top, either linked to spend or to performance. This balances predictability for both sides with some flexibility. It’s often the most practical structure for mid-sized and larger businesses.
Performance-based. Part or all of the fee depends on agreed outcomes, such as qualified leads, revenue or profit. In theory this is the best alignment. In practice it only works when measurement is reliable, the agency has meaningful influence over the outcome and both sides agree on how external factors like pricing, stock or sales team capacity are treated. Fully performance-based models are rare for good reason. A modest performance element within a hybrid structure is usually more workable.
An illustrative comparison
The figures below are purely illustrative, not based on any client. Take a business spending £40k a month on paid search, rising to £60k in peak season.
On a flat 10% of spend, the fee would be £4k in a normal month and £6k in peak. On a tiered model charging 10% up to £30k and 6% above it, the fee would be £3.6k normally and £4.8k in peak. On a hybrid of a £3k retainer plus a performance bonus of up to £1.5k when agreed CRM-based targets are met, the fee would range from £3k to £4.5k regardless of spend.
None of these is automatically better. The point of running the numbers is to understand what each model rewards, and whether that matches what you want from the relationship.
What to put in the contract
Whatever the model, a few clauses do most of the work.
Define the scope clearly: which channels, which activities (strategy, build, optimisation, reporting, creative, tracking) and what level of senior involvement is included. Ambiguous scope is the most common source of disagreement.
Agree targets in commercial terms, the source of truth for measuring them and how often they’re reviewed. A quarterly review gives you space to adjust for market changes without renegotiating the whole agreement.
Set out how budget changes are proposed and approved. Any material change should come with a rationale and an expected outcome, and should be agreed in writing.
Specify service levels that matter in practice, such as response times, reporting cadence, a named account lead and notice of team changes.
Confirm ownership and access. The ad accounts, tracking, data and creative should belong to the business, with the agency given user access. This makes audits, transitions and independent reviews straightforward.
Finally, include sensible notice periods and a clear handover process. A good agency won’t object to either.
Measuring value beyond the platform
A performance element is only as good as the measurement behind it. For lead generation, platform conversions usually count form fills or calls, many of which never become customers. Importing offline conversions from your CRM, such as qualified leads, opportunities and closed revenue, lets both the bidding algorithms and the contract work towards outcomes that actually matter. Google Ads supports this through offline conversion imports and enhanced conversions for leads, which match CRM records back to ad clicks using hashed first-party data.
For ecommerce, revenue alone can mislead when margins vary widely across products. Reporting on gross profit, or feeding margin data into bidding through conversion values, gives a truer picture.
It’s also worth agreeing in advance what counts as incremental. Brand search, returning customers and promotions can all inflate reported performance. Simple controls, such as reporting brand and non-brand separately or running periodic geo or holdout tests, keep the conversation honest.
Choosing the right model
As a rough guide, businesses with stable budgets and well-defined needs tend to do well on retainers, while those with seasonal spend often prefer a tiered or capped percentage. Businesses with mature measurement and a clear link between marketing and revenue are best placed to introduce a performance element. If measurement isn’t there yet, fixing it is usually a better first step than changing the fee model.
The most useful test is whether the structure makes it easy for your agency to give you advice that reduces its own income. If it does, the incentives are probably in the right place.