Magnifying glass resting on a polished wooden desk in warm light

PPC Strategy

5 min read

19 Oct 2026

Is your PPC working? How to evaluate your setup before changing agency or team

When paid search performance disappoints, the instinct is often to change who’s running it. Sometimes that’s right. But a change of agency or team takes months to settle, costs time internally and frequently doesn’t fix the underlying problem, because the issue sat in tracking, targets or the business itself rather than in day-to-day management. A structured evaluation beforehand tells you whether a change is needed and, if it is, what the next partner needs to do differently.

This is a framework for running that evaluation, whether you do it internally or with an independent specialist.

Step one: check that the numbers are true

Every other judgement depends on measurement, so start there. Confirm which conversion actions are set as primary and therefore used for bidding. It’s common to find micro-conversions, duplicate tags or outdated actions influencing Smart Bidding. Check that conversion values reflect something real, such as revenue, margin or the relative value of lead types, rather than a placeholder figure.

Then compare platform data with your own systems. Google Ads conversions should be broadly in line with what your CRM, ecommerce platform or analytics tool records, allowing for attribution differences. A large or growing gap is a finding in its own right. Check consent mode and enhanced conversions too, since gaps in either can quietly reduce the data available to bidding.

If measurement turns out to be unreliable, that’s often the most important conclusion of the whole exercise. Changing agency won’t help if the next one is optimising towards the same flawed signals.

Step two: judge performance against the right baseline

Performance only means something relative to a sensible benchmark. Compare year on year rather than month on month, and look at what changed in the business over the same period: pricing, product range, stock, website changes, sales team capacity and the competitive landscape. Paid search is very sensitive to these factors, and agencies are often blamed for problems that originated elsewhere.

Look at whether the targets themselves were realistic. A target ROAS or cost per lead set when CPCs were lower, or before a price change, may no longer be achievable. Equally, an account that’s comfortably hitting a target may have been set too easy a one, leaving growth unclaimed.

Step three: review the account structure and strategy

With measurement and context understood, look at how the account is run. Useful questions include whether the campaign structure reflects how the business makes money, for example separating high- and low-margin product groups or lead types with different values; whether brand and non-brand are reported and managed separately; how budget is allocated relative to where returns are highest; and whether automation such as Performance Max, broad match or AI Max is being used with appropriate controls, exclusions and data inputs.

The search terms report is one of the most revealing places to look. It shows what you’re actually paying for, and quickly highlights whether broad targeting is controlled or drifting.

Review the change history as well. An account with very little activity over several months may be under-managed. One with constant large changes may be unstable. Neither is automatically wrong, but both are worth asking about.

Step four: assess the working relationship

Some problems aren’t about the account at all. Consider whether reporting explains what happened and why, or simply lists metrics. Look at whether the agency or team brings ideas proactively, connects recommendations to commercial outcomes and is open about what isn’t working. Ask whether you’re getting the level of senior involvement you expected.

It’s also worth looking at your own side. Clear objectives, timely access to business information and someone internally with the authority to make decisions all have a significant effect on what any agency or team can achieve.

Step five: decide what the findings mean

The evaluation usually points to one of four outcomes. If measurement or targets are the problem, fix them first and reassess after a few months. If the account is sound but the relationship isn’t, a direct conversation about expectations may be enough. If the strategy or execution is weak and previous feedback hasn’t led to change, a move is probably justified. And if everything is broadly working, the evaluation gives you evidence to support the current approach internally, which is a useful result in itself.

If you do decide to change, the findings become the brief. A new partner who receives a clear diagnosis of the measurement, the context and the gaps can start working on the right problems straight away, rather than spending the first few months rediscovering them.

Getting an independent view

An evaluation is most useful when the person doing it has no stake in the outcome. That could be a trusted specialist, an internal analyst with paid search knowledge or an independent audit. Propel’s free Google Ads audit at audit.propeldigital.com is one option for a structured starting point. It uses read-only access, which is deleted once the audit is complete.